List of International Peer-Reviewed Journals. Journal Network manages over peer-reviewed, open access publications. We supply out own managing editors while connecting well-qualified and vetted associate editors to publication submission to provide additional review services. All titles are indexed in UlrichsWeb and Google Scholar Figure-9the , only a few peer reviewed journals were available for research publication in Ayurveda and other Indian systems of healthcare. The Journal of Research in Indian Medicine (JRIM), published from BHU under financial grant aid of Govt. of India Peer-edited means a journal that is edited by professionals in the field. Refereed means a journal that routinely sends article submissions on for peer review by members of a diverse professional group. Student-edited or peer-edited journals may also be refereed,
List of International Peer-Reviewed Journals - Journal Network
To browse Academia. edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser. Skip to main content. edu no longer supports Internet Explorer. Log In Sign Up. Download Free PDF, peer edited journals. PEER REVIEWED JOURNALS OF AYURVEDA - AN APPRAISAL. Kishor Patwardhan. Prof SURESH KUMAR.
PRATAP THAKUR. Galib Galib. Download PDF. Peer edited journals Full PDF Package This paper. A short summary of this paper. READ PAPER. Introduction Process of scholarly publication:Scientific publication is the process by which any research outcome enters the public domain. It is essential that the results of a research work are published so that the information related to a specific stream of knowledge is kept updated from time to time.
Without publications, peer edited journals cannot progress. Broadly, the scientific publications may be of two varieties: a. Popular and b, peer edited journals. In the present paper we limit the discussion mostly to scholarly literature. Nonetheless, it is pertinent to note the differences between these two kinds of literature, peer edited journals.
In 'popular' literature; shorter articles furnishing broader overview are published: authors often are not the specialists in the subject and credentials of the authors are often not provided, peer edited journals. Such articles are written in nontechnical style and do not follow a specific format. These peer edited journals are neither evaluated by experts in the field.
Several periodicals such as newsletters and magazines fall under this category. Articles falling under 'scholarly' category are usually longer, providing deeper insights of a topic; author is an expert in the field, whose credentials are always provided. Furthermore, these are structured articles i. They are assessed and critically evaluated by a panel of experts. These experts are known as peer-reviewers. Peer review ensures that the science entering the public domain is sound, interesting and relevant.
It also assists authors and editors in publishing quality research. Based on whether the identity peer edited journals the authors and the reviewers is disclosed to each peer edited journals, the process of peer review has been divided into two categories: 'Blinded' and 'Open'. Blinded peer review could again be either 'single blinded' when the authors do not know who the reviewer is; but the reviewers know the identity of the authors and 'double blinded' both reviewers and authors do not know each others' identity.
Based on whether the review is performed before or after the publication, it is of two kinds: 'pre-publication' and 'post-publication'. Scenario of scholarly publication in Ayurveda:There peer edited journals quite a few journals that publish research related to Ayurveda. They can be grouped as follows: a, peer edited journals. Basic Science Journals b. Biomedical Journals c. CAM Journals d. AYUSH Journals e. It is to be noted that when compared with other streams such as acupuncture, acupressure, traditional Chinese medicine and Osteopathy, the number of research articles published in the field of AYUSH is far too low.
The major reason for this scenario is limited awareness regarding the importance of publishing, peer edited journals. It is also to be peer edited journals that no training is given in scientific writing during formal Ayurveda education, which further adds to the problem. Differences between Magazines, Newsletters, Journals and Books are also not clearly known to Ayurveda researchers. A lack of awareness about the important guidelines and methods of reporting while planning and publishing the research-adds further to the problem.
aspx is as follows:. DHARA also gives a list of 10 most searched journals for Ayurveda and allied subjects on their DHARA database, which, as on 20 th December, is as follows: Arranged alphabetically. Since its inception, JREIM has maintained and is enjoying its nonaligned and independent academic status. Manual peer review through postal services and publication of scientific journals through letter press was a difficult and challenging task.
This prevented others to start and publish double blinded peer reviewed journals for years. In the peer edited journals past, with general awareness and easy access to computers and automated Journalmanagement systems with online paperless peer review and publication systems available free of cost many new journals have come up, but till today for want of Standard Operating Procedures, peer edited journals, the quality of review and publication in India, especially in AYUSH sector has remained far away from the International status.
The present work is thus aimed at studying the present status of Peer Reviewed Journals of Ayurveda and to propose further actions to enable Ayurveda research to become visible on the various scientific platforms. ObjectiveThe objective of the present study was to critically analyze and report the status of peer reviewed journals of Ayurveda. Methods and MaterialsA comprehensive search was peer edited journals and relevant offline and online sources were consulted.
Most of the known periodicals and journals of Ayurveda among the academicians are included in this attempt, and the inclusion was primarily based on the 'scope of the journal' as described by the editorial boards of the journals. We included those journals that mentioned 'Traditional Indian medicine', 'South Asian traditional medicine', 'Complementary and Alternative medicine' or 'Ayurveda' under the section 'Scope of the journal'. We had to draw this line of limitation because, as a principle, any biomedical journal can publish a relevant research paper on Ayurveda.
We did not include those journals that have published some occasional articles on Ayurveda. pdf Observations and ResultsWe could list 20 monthly, 37 quarterly, peer edited journals, 15 bimonthly, 5 half yearly and 1 yearly periodicals.
However, peer edited journals, clear data was not available peer edited journals 5 periodicals. Five journals provided discount to students. Seven journals peer edited journals irregular in periodicity and three were found to have been discontinued. English 62 is being used as the language of communication in most of the periodicals followed by bilingual 9multilingual 4Hindi 6 and Gujarati 2.
Out of all the periodicals, 47 declared themselves as 'peer reviewed' and 31 were of general non-peer reviewed nature. Further, 5 of them belonged to the category of newsletters. DiscussionUpon analysis, the journals publishing exclusively AYUSH research were found to be deficient in many aspects related to the standards of scientific publishing.
Journals indexed with standard peer edited journals such as PubMed and Science Direct were generally found to be better than others because of their transparent policies. A few newer journals claimed to have fake Impact Factors and other fake Journal Metrics, which is a point of concern. As the journal management needs funding, these journals tend to accept even substandard articles for the sake of money.
Publishing has become a good business opportunity, as UGC and other academic bodies make it mandatory to have publications for promotions and recruitments of teachers. This makes several peer edited journals 'desperate' to publish. When the work is rejected by standard journals, these authors usually go for 'author pays' model of open access. Many journals, therefore, do not actually perform peer-review in its actual rigor.
Plagiarism is another major problem that was noted. Temptations for 'copy and paste' could be potentially dangerous as one should not lift someone else's paragraph without citing the source.
Even if the source is cited, paraphrasing is necessary. We noted a few cases of research violations in our study, the most important being a failure to disclose conflict of interest.
A few cases of redundant publication authors publishing the same paper in a number of different journalsSalami Slicing publishing the same data in different forms in different journals were also noted during the course of this study. Ethical issues such as handling animals, and registration of clinical trials with Clinical Trial Registry of India CTRI were not addressed to, in many articles. They are more inclined towards publishing the studies related to their own products. This practice needs to stop; else, the conflict of interest that is evident may pose a threat to the advancement in the science.
Scarce Governmental funding:The journals published by Government organizations-like AYUSH, NIA and CCRAS etc, peer edited journals. suffer from paucity of funds, technical manpower and mismanagement. Closure of AYUSH-funded International Journal of Ayurveda Research IJAR is one such example for the governmental apathy.
These journals are usually irregular, but when they are published they contain the data of the studies conducted mostly at their own respective institutes. No incentives for good work:There is routinely no provision for rewarding the good publications, peer edited journals.
Lack of training in scientific writing:Currently, the students are mostly not formally trained in writing research papers during their post graduate studies. Quality training in research methods, protocol designing, medical statistics and scientific writing would be essential RecommendationsThrough this article, we would like to suggest few steps to improve the quality of scientific publications in Ayurveda sector, peer edited journals.
The efforts of Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine J-AIM in the recent years in this regard are noteworthy. A peer edited journals to rate the existing journals must be taken up by a neutral agency to aid the researchers in selecting the right kind of journals. The editors of AYUSH journals must come up with some standard and uniform guidelines to report various kinds of peer edited journals. The CONSORTIA is one such recent promising initiative.
Limitations of the studyThe list of journals that we have provided in this work is not exhaustive. aspx refered journals that have published articles on Ayurveda, CAM, Intigrative Medicne and related topics.
ConclusionThough, there is a huge number of biomedical journals publishing research on Ayurveda; it appears that particularly Ayurveda journals are still in the stage of infancy.
During last couple of years, Ayurveda sector has witnessed mushrooming growth of new journals-mostly open access and online ones. However, most of them are struggling to maintain the expected standards.
Researchers need to be careful and must make sure that, their work is not being communicated to predatory journals.
Peer Review in 3 Minutes
, time: 3:16Peer-reviewed journal articles | Library | University of Waterloo
8/27/ · Peer-reviewed journal articles undergo an evaluation conducted by experts in a particular field of study. These experts determine whether an article meets the criteria for inclusion in a journal. This process helps ensure that the research described in the articles is original and of high quality. Another term for peer reviewed is refereed Make the best use of Researched information from + peer reviewed, Open Access Journals operated by 50,+ Editorial Board Members and esteemed reviewers and + Scientific associations in Medical, Clinical, Pharmaceutical, Engineering, Technology and Management Fields Figure-9the , only a few peer reviewed journals were available for research publication in Ayurveda and other Indian systems of healthcare. The Journal of Research in Indian Medicine (JRIM), published from BHU under financial grant aid of Govt. of India
No comments:
Post a Comment